Foreclosure Defense: Why Discovery Is Where Cases Are Won

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and not legal advice. Always consult with an attorney licensed in the jurisdiction of your case.

Discovery, Not Trial, Is the Real Battleground

Too many homeowners think they’ll get their day in court at trial. In truth, foreclosure cases are usually won—or lost—in discovery.

Banks and servicers rely on stonewalling. They respond to simple “yes” or “no” questions with vague objections like “ambiguous” or “irrelevant.” Without forcing answers through a Motion to Compel, homeowners never get the facts that expose the truth about the loan, the money trail, and the players involved.

The key: file discovery requests, anticipate objections, and be prepared with a persuasive brief that explains why the questions are relevant, why you need answers, and why there’s no other way to obtain the information.

Why Banks Avoid the Money Trail

Every major settlement in foreclosure cases has come only after a judge ordered the servicer or bank to reveal the full money trail:

• Who funded the loan at “origination”?

• Where did borrower payments actually go?

• What other payments (like insurance or servicer advances) were made on the account?

When forced to answer these questions, banks almost always settle quickly. Why? Because the truth exposes that:

• The “originator” often never funded the loan.

• Assignments were executed by nonexistent entities.

• Foreclosures are driven not by creditors, but by servicers chasing reimbursement for servicer advances—payments they volunteered to make, unrelated to borrower default.

Case Example: Wells Fargo

In one case, Wells Fargo claimed in the complaint to be the owner of the loan. At trial, their representative admitted:

• Wells was not the owner, but “only the servicer.”

• The alleged originator wasn’t the lender.

• Freddie Mac was supposedly “the investor from the start.”

• An assignment in the record came from a nonexistent entity.

Yet Wells Fargo still pursued foreclosure without:

• Producing a servicing or agency agreement with Freddie Mac.

• Showing any evidence that Freddie Mac ever funded or purchased the loan.

• Demonstrating how Wells Fargo could suffer a financial loss on borrower default.

The obvious motive? Servicer advances. Wells Fargo needed a foreclosure judgment to justify collecting back its advances—even though those payments were made voluntarily and never created a borrower obligation.

Why a Motion to Compel Is Critical

When servicers dodge discovery, the Motion to Compel becomes the turning point. Your motion should:

1. Highlight evasive answers. Example: A yes/no question answered with “vague and ambiguous” objections.

2. Explain relevance. Show how the information goes directly to standing, ownership, and damages.

3. Expose contradictions. If they admit they’re not the lender or owner, demand to know who is—and how the money trail worked.

Supporting your motion with a memo that outlines these inconsistencies makes it hard for a judge to ignore.

Practice Pointers

• Ask about the IT platforms. Which systems track payments? Who has access? Stonewalling here often reveals third-party data managers like Black Knight or CoreLogic.

• Focus on the funding. If the “originator” had no bank account or capacity to lend, who provided the money?

• Challenge servicer standing. If they admit they didn’t fund the loan, own the debt, or represent the creditor, what authority do they have to foreclose?

• Press on servicer advances. These payments prove investors were kept whole, undermining claims of default.

The Bottom Line

Foreclosure cases aren’t decided on flashy trial arguments. They’re won by relentless discovery that unmasks the illusion of ownership and exposes the absence of a creditor with a legitimate loss.

If your opponent can’t (or won’t) answer simple questions, that’s often the strongest evidence you’ll ever get. Use it to push your Motion to Compel—and build the record that can stop a foreclosure.

Need Help With Your Case?

Call us today at 844.583.5339
Submit your case statement online for a complimentary recommendation.
Visit LivingLies.me for resources and case insights.

Tags: dsicovery, foreclosure defense, money trail, Servicer advances
Posted in discovery |