When is the assignment of mortgage effective against the homeowner?

What Makes a Mortgage Assignment Effective?

For an assignment of mortgage to be effective:

• The property owner must be given notice by the current mortgage holder.

• The new owner must be clearly identified.

• The mortgage must be recorded and appear facially valid (in compliance with statute).

There is no time limit on recording, but validity depends on more than appearances.

Why “Facially Valid” Doesn’t Mean Valid

Just because an assignment exists on paper doesn’t mean it’s legally enforceable:

• If the underlying obligation (the actual loan account receivable) wasn’t transferred for value, the assignment is a legal nullity.

• Courts often presume the obligation was transferred when the note is endorsed — but that presumption can be challenged.

Under UCC 9-203, adopted in all U.S. jurisdictions, a claimant must prove the purchase and sale of the obligation. Without it, foreclosure fails.

Article 9 vs. Article 3: The Key Difference

• Article 3 governs enforcement of notes.

• Article 9 governs foreclosure of security instruments.

A party can sometimes win a judgment on a note without owning the debt. But no one can foreclose a mortgage without owning the obligation.

Failing to raise this issue in court waives it. Judges will presume validity unless you challenge it with discovery, QWRs (Qualified Written Requests), or DVLs (Debt Validation Letters).

The Problem with Signatures on Assignments

Don’t assume the person signing an assignment of mortgage had authority. In many cases:

• The signatory wasn’t authorized.

• The entity named had no interest in the loan.

• The recorded document may look right but memorialize a transaction that never occurred.

If no value was paid, the assignment — and the mortgage lien itself — is void.

How to Test for a Real Transaction

You can test whether a real business transaction occurred by demanding:

• QWRs (Qualified Written Requests)

• DVLs (Debt Validation Letters)

• Discovery responses in litigation

Only accept corroboration from the named claimant — not just a “servicer.”

Most servicers don’t even handle funds. The CFPB has identified FINTECH companies as the ones actually receiving and disbursing homeowner payments. Yet courts are misled into believing servicers hold authority.

What This Means for Foreclosure Defense

If no real transaction occurred:

• The mortgage assignment is void.

• The lien cannot serve as the basis for foreclosure.

• The named claimant has no standing.

Challenging these issues early can delay enforcement for years — and in rare cases, even eliminate the lien entirely.

⚖️ Important Note: Foreclosure defense is not simple and there are no guarantees. But challenging servicers and claimants before enforcement can buy critical time — and sometimes lead to extraordinary results.

If you need representation:
📧 Email Neil Garfield at neilfgarfield@hotmail.com to retain him as a legal consultant.

✅ Bottom Line: A mortgage assignment without proof of an underlying debt transfer is void. Don’t let facially valid but substantively invalid documents strip you of your home. Challenge them with evidence and experienced legal counsel.

Posted in Uncategorized |